We all want to feel understood, but one of the things I loved about my conversation with my friend Yael Schonbrun is how clearly she shows that understanding another person is much harder than simply listening to them. Yael is a clinical psychologist, couples therapist, assistant professor at Brown University, and the author of Work, Parent, Thrive and Why Don’t You Understand Me? Across her research, private practice, and writing, she brings together psychology, relationship science, philosophy, and the patterns she sees every day working with couples. Her new book explores why even people who love each other and are genuinely trying to communicate can walk away from the same conversation with completely different ideas about what happened.
Perspective-Getting and Better Communication in Relationships
A big reason is that we’re constantly filling in the gaps. We hear someone’s words, notice a facial expression, remember part of an interaction, and then our brains construct a story about what the other person was thinking or intending. The closer we are to someone, the more confident we can become that we already know what they mean. Yael introduced me to the idea of perspective-getting, which I loved. Instead of only trying to put yourself in someone else’s shoes and guessing what they might be feeling, you actually ask them. That requires humility and the willingness to admit that your version of reality might be incomplete. And it also creates an opportunity for much deeper connection.
How Curiosity Can Help Us Feel More Seen and Understood
This conversation felt personal because I’ve realized how my own habit of reading the room and anticipating other people’s reactions can sometimes keep me from saying what I actually need. I can think I’m being accommodating or protecting a relationship when I’m really not giving the other person a chance to understand me at all. Yael and I talk about people-pleasing, positive regard, resentment, parenting, difficult conversations, and what happens when we approach the people we love with a little less certainty and a little more curiosity. Maybe feeling more understood starts there: not with perfect communication, but with being brave enough to ask, listen, clarify, and let someone else surprise us.
Top Takeaways
- Listening and understanding are not the same thing: Hearing someone’s words is only the beginning. Understanding requires us to interpret what they mean and that’s where our own stories and biases can get in the way.
- We are not as good at mind reading as we think: Especially with people close to us, our confidence about what they think or feel often exceeds our actual accuracy.
- Try perspective-getting instead of perspective-taking: Rather than imagining what someone else feels, ask them.
- Humility makes deeper understanding possible: Two people can experience the same situation differently without either person being dishonest or malicious.
- Feeling understood requires vulnerability: If we hide what we need because we’re afraid of someone’s reaction, we may unintentionally prevent the very intimacy and trust we want.
- Positive regard helps relationships recover: Seeing the whole person creates more room for repair, curiosity, and connection.
LINKS
– Pre-Order Yael’s Newest Book: Why Don’t You Understand Me? The Surprising Science of Connecting in a World of Missed Signals.
– Learn more about Yael on her website
– Listen to Work, Parent, Thrive with Psychologist Yael Schonbrun
– Listen to Navigating Love: A Deep Dive into Relationships with Yael Schonbrun
___


Transcript
Sonya Looney 0:00
Oh my gosh, y’all! I’m so excited to have you on the podcast to talk about your second book coming out.
Yael Schonbrun 0:07
I’m so excited to. I’m always excited to chat with you, but for podcast is is own fun special thing.
Sonya Looney 0:14
So tell us the title of your book and why you wrote it.
Yael Schonbrun 0:19
The title is “Why Don’t You Understand Me. The subtitle is the surprising science of connecting in a world of missed signals, and the the background, the the sort of impetus to actually landing on this book topic is that I was working on something totally different, a totally different book project, and it was about problem solving and how we go about problem solving in the wrong way, and it just wasn’t gelling. And I was on a walk with my family, inventing to my husband about how it wasn’t gelling. And I was like, I should just chuck that whole thing and write a book about how everybody thinks they understand everybody else, and nobody feels understood because it’s what I do all day in my clinical practice because I treat couples, and my husband turns to me and he’s like, “Yeah, write that book. And so it was like this light bulb moment of why am I not writing this book? Because this is my background in research. This is what I do clinically. This is the thing that I’m constantly thinking about because I’m so fascinated by relationships and why people misunderstand one another, even when they think they’re understanding one another perfectly, and so that was the genesis of actually writing the book. But it is something that I do regularly in my clinical practice, where I specialize in the treatment of couples.
Sonya Looney 1:34
I love that, and you know, as I’m I’m learning about book writing as well, and book writing is a process of becoming, and you learn a lot about yourself and about even your topic that you’re writing about as it’s unfolding in front of you. So, what was one or two things that surprised you as you were writing this book? Because you you had all the experience, but then you were doing research and reading and writing.
Yael Schonbrun 1:57
Hmm. Let’s see. Like, where should I begin about the things that I didn’t know. I mean, the process of writing is always a surprise. But in terms of the the research, there were some things that I didn’t initially plan to focus on as heavily that became their own chapters. And I’ll say maybe two examples. So one is language. I have this whole chapter dedicated to the ambiguity of language and the evolution of language, and I didn’t know anything about the evolution of language. And in that chapter, I also talk about what we can learn from the ant world about communication and how we do it differently. And these were things that I did not know anything about, but it was so interesting how that that knowledge, that research on the evolution of language and language’s ambiguity fits into what I do know about relationship cognition and an interpersonal misunderstanding. We can get into that. The other thing that was really fun to learn about was the science of humor and how humor really can let people’s minds and hearts open, and how it does that, and how humor can be used skillfully, and how how and when does it fail us? Because sometimes it does fail us, but using humor as a tool and and knowing how to use it effectively was something that I didn’t like. I sort of had the sense that like humor humor seems like it should be a tool because I see couples there. I know that research on humor in marriages suggests that couples who are able to kind of laugh are able to diffuse conflict. But I was curious, sort of like in a given conversation, how can humor be helpful? And that was new information to me and really fun to dig into.
Sonya Looney 3:39
I was actually really grateful for that chapter myself because today I was talking to one of my best friends who was going to have a conversation that she was very nervous about, and I was like, you know, you can use humor, and here’s how you can use humor. So that’s already being put into action.
Yael Schonbrun 3:52
Awesome, that’s awesome. You’re you’re spreading the word, the good word.
Sonya Looney 3:57
So something that you did a really amazing job with is really showing the difference between listening versus understanding. Can you tell us what that
Yael Schonbrun 4:07
is? Yeah. So this is something that really is at the heart of the book that we conflate communication and understanding, and specifically listening and understanding. Listening is is sort of more of a perceptual thing, like you know, hearing words, but understanding them goes many steps deeper. And you know, we can hear a word that gets communicated to us, but to understand it takes a lot more cognitive and emotional effort. And a lot of that effort happens outside of our conscious awareness. But understanding is more like the process of not just perceiving things, but decoding it and then making meaning. And when we do that in ways that don’t match up with what the sender of the communication, the words, is intending, they feel misunderstood. So what we. Understand when it doesn’t match up to what they intended to communicate to us leaves them with the feeling of being misunderstood, even if we understand perfectly. Whereas listening is like, did you hear the words? It’s a lot more like concrete of what did you perceive and can you sort of feedback, and that’s a big reason why the the communication advice regarding reflective listening. So somebody says something, you ask me a question, I say, “Here’s what I heard you say. Can you tell me that what listening means? And that’s not hard to do, but that won’t necessarily leave you feeling deeply understood because the work has to go deeper for that to happen.
Sonya Looney 5:42
Yeah, and like my head almost explodes when I think about all of the different things in your books. It’s it was so well done with all of the different ways that you can actually learn how to understand other people, but also yourself. I have a quote. I I remember sending this quote to you whenever I read it because I was like, oh my gosh, this is brilliant. So I wanted to bring it into the podcast, and then we can talk about it. You said the symbolic nature of human language creates both our greatest achievements and our most persistent misunderstandings. When we hear someone speak, we’re not just processing their words; we are reconstructing what they’re thinking, feeling, and wanting us to understand. And what I love about that is the word reconstructing. We are reconstructing what they’re feeling, thinking, feeling, and wanting us to understand. So, what are some of the ways it goes wrong with that reconstruction of what we think somebody else is thinking, feeling, and wanting us to understand?
Yael Schonbrun 6:33
Oh gosh, there’s so many ways, and I’ll just draw on my clinical experience, and and because I’m an active private practice clinician. What I’ll also just say, sort of like, so people know, is that I’ll share stories that sound like a person, but what they really are is compilations and anonymized. So they’re patterns that I see all the time. But I’ll talk about it as as if it’s an individual case, just because it’s easier to follow. But take for example a couple where one person is really longing for emotional intimacy, and the way that they receive emotional intimacy is through conversation. They want to have deep, deep conversations about how we’re feeling and share about our days and talk about the meaning of life. And the other partner is much more inclined to want, and and you could think about this from like a love languages perspective. Like the other partner really wants to connect through through touch, right? Through affection and through time spent together. So when one person says like I want to talk, and the other person feels a little bit uncomfortable with that, like oh you’re going to ask me for something that I don’t feel very equipped to offer you, and then you’re going to be really disappointed when I can’t meet the desire of having this kind of deep communication because that that isn’t something that I’m very skilled at doing. The person who wants to talk is going to say, “What you are intending by that is you’re avoiding me, and you don’t want to meet me where I’m at, right? So that’s like a decoding of a message that is almost like the absence. The absence of your words is meaningful to me. Now, when that person says, “I really want to talk, and I’m really hurt that you don’t want to talk, the other person, the more physically oriented person, is going to decode those words as saying, “I don’t like who you are. Who you are is not enough for me. Right? The words are, “I’m unhappy, but we, in our heads, can so easily go to the next place. And this is just a really common example of something that I see in the therapy room all the time. But it can go even in words that are abundantly clear. That like seem like the the message is very obvious to one person, but maybe constructed differently for another. Like you can have one couple where one partner says, “I love you” all the time after every conversation, and to them, it’s like I love you, right? That’s an expression of my feeling. But to the other person, using I love you that much starts to make it feel not very meaningful, right? And so you have a different association, even though the literal meaning of the word love is exactly the same, but the how it’s used can be interpreted very differently. Those are just two really common examples, but you can see just from those two examples that it has to do with the relationship that we have to words. It has to do with the construction that we make in how we understand the way that other people’s minds work. This is called theory of mind. This is something that humans do when one person is interacting with another, we take guesses at what’s on their mind and what’s motivating them and what the behaviors mean. It’s just something that humans naturally do, and we’re pretty good at it. But we’re not perfect because we’re not actually mind readers. And then there’s sort of the the. Sequencing of meaning that we take. Well, if you meant that, and then you’re thinking that, then this is how I’m going to understand not just your words, but who you are as a person. And you can see how there’s this ripple effect that then, as interactions continue on, the more words you say, or the more ways that we interact, I’m carrying this idea of who you are and interpreting it through that filter of you’re somebody who doesn’t like me, right? And so you say something kind of neutral, but I interpret it as more evidence.
Yael Schonbrun 10:33
Or you’re somebody who’s very selfish, and so if you ask me a question, I immediately think, well, how does that serve your needs, right? And I can usually find something because that’s our human minds are really good at finding evidence for what we already believe, and so you can see these starting points just rippling out and compounding in misunderstandings that don’t, for us in the moment, feel like misunderstands. We feel like we’re understanding perfectly because it all kind of fits in the construction that we’ve made,
Sonya Looney 11:02
yeah, it’s so funny. The judging and the bias, and then the the stories that we tell ourselves, can really be inaccurate of what somebody is trying to to do. Like even I was telling you about a friend of mine before we turned on the the mics, and like my interpretation of what that person was doing might actually not even be real. It’s just what I understand it to be. So, like, what do we do about this problem?
Yael Schonbrun 11:30
Yeah, it’s sort of it’s like a what do we do if we start to recognize that so much of our perception of reality is a construction, and and that there’s a lot of subjectivity, and there’s a lot of I don’t know storytelling that we do that may or may not match onto reality, and part of that is it it feels disorienting for us. Like if I don’t like if I was to question all of reality, like are you really Sonya? Are we really doing a podcast? I would feel crazy, and it would be hard to figure out like what to do in in a life, right? If you had to question everything, and then there’s this other piece that’s if I have an experience of reality that feels real to me, and you have an experience of reality that feels real to you, and they don’t match up. What then, right? So there’s like my own shoot, like that’s kind of scary. But like, say I can get comfortable with. Okay, my perception of reality may not be perfect, but it’s pretty solid. And now yours is you feel the same way, and they don’t align. And and what we know happens. There’s really interesting research on this idea of the fundamental human need for shared reality. When we don’t have a shared reality, because it is so constructed and therefore we can construct it differently, that this is incredibly unsettling relationally, and we feel unsafe around people who experience a different reality than we do. Sorry. Can I?
Sonya Looney 13:10
No, that’s it.
Yael Schonbrun 13:12
Can I pause and put him in the downstairs room? Okay. All right. Sorry.
Sonya Looney 13:17
It’s okay. Gives me a minute to regroup.
Yael Schonbrun 14:10
I had a feeling that would happen. That’s good.
Sonya Looney 14:12
It’s so funny. Okay, we’re not recording yet, Anthony. Jump back and what you’re talking about. I actually have the chapter open, like on my computer. So I was like so excited. I was like, “Yes, I can go to the chapter real quick.
Yael Schonbrun 14:24
I love that. Was actually, I mean, I don’t that I knew about shared reality, but it was so fun to dig into that because that is something that comes up all the time in couples therapy, and that I’ve experienced too. Like when somebody’s like, “This is what happened, and you’re like, “No, it’s not like you’re gaslighting me. Or who do you think I am? I’m not. I’m not stupid. Like I saw with my own eyes. But what’s so? I don’t know if you want to record this. But what’s so what’s so interesting about shared reality and the construction of reality is that two people can, by totally honest means. Arrive at totally different ideas of what happened, and in fact, research on people who are in the same relationship and what happened in their relationship in the same week shows that they disagree a huge percent of the time, like 20 to 40% of the time. They arrive at different reports of did we have sex? Did we take a walk? Did we have a conversation about X, Y, or Z? And it’s because of perception. Like we pay attention to different things, and reality is so complicated that I may pay attention to the leaves, and you’re paying attention to the flowers on the ground. And so, you know, when you say the leaves were blooming, and I the leaves are changing color, and I say, “Well, the flowers were blooming. Like we have different ideas of reality, and we’re not either of us wrong, but like we paid attention to different things. And then memory is reconstructive rather than recalled. And so, when we sort of make meaning or pay attention, and then we make a story about it, like the stories that we tell are going to look really different, and that can be really disorienting and unsettling. If you’re in a relationship and you’re trying to make sense of the world together, that it can feel really divisive, and it can feel like you can’t trust the other person because the alternative to to not trusting the other person is not trusting your own perception of reality, and so to go back, I’m so long-winded in this in this answer. But to go back to the question of like, what do you do with it? I think the more that we can practice just recognizing that we perceive things and we do so really well and imperfectly, and and that idea can give us a little bit of humility. Like this is what I saw. That doesn’t mean there’s there’s all there is. And then if we can have some humility, and then in the next step, curiosity. Like wow, I had a really different idea of what happened. How did you arrive at your description of what happened? Like, what were you paying attention to? What was going on for you? And that curiosity and humility together can help you kind of expand the reality and recognize that there’s more going on than any of our brains can take in in a given moment, right? Social realities are so complex, and so it’s not because you’re not paying attention. It’s because you can only pay attention to so many things, and it’s not because your partner or your friend or your political opponent is an evil, malicious, ignorant person. It’s because they’re paying attention and making meaning and and constructing their reality in different ways for different reasons, and if we can understand that, if we can sort of hold our reality a little more lightly, not not say like I don’t have an idea of what’s real and what’s not, but like I have an idea of what’s real and it’s imperfect, and I only can gather a certain amount of information, and you also have a imperfect sense of reality, and together we can create a more comprehensive whole reality because we’re each going to take in valuable information, and if we can help one another to dig deeper on important truths, important senses of what’s going on, then that empowers us. But in order to do that, we need to be humble about our own and not dismiss what is perceived differently.
Sonya Looney 18:30
Yeah, I love how it’s really about like focusing on the process of how somebody got to where they’re at instead of judging where you think that they’re at. In your book, you had this really amazing story about these two people. I think one person was like a white loyalist or something. I can’t remember the exact same. Yeah, white nationalist.
Yael Schonbrun 18:48
A
Sonya Looney 18:48
white nationalist. Yeah, and like, yeah. Can you tell us about that? Because I I thought that was a really powerful story. Because so many of us have so much judgment towards other people, and we feel like we can never get to a place of shared understanding.
Yael Schonbrun 19:00
Yeah. So it was this beautiful story, and I came across this story in a Pulitzer Prize-winning book called “Rising Out of Hatred, and it turned out that, and so the the the the book was based on the story of of this kid who was born as by the name Derek Black, she now goes by Adrienne Black. She’s transgendered, but she had been brought up in this white nationalist household at the heart of the white nationalist community. In fact, her godfather was David Duke, who’s a well-known KKK leader, and her father was the founder of Stormfront, which is the most popular white nationalist website, and like from I think in her early teen years to early adulthood, she co-hosted a podcast about white nationalist issues with her father, and she became interested in in medieval studies and ended up at a liberal arts college in in Florida. Which was a fairly liberal liberal arts college, and she knew like my views are not going to be welcome here, but I feel them keenly, so I’ll just be quiet about them and go about my studies. At some point, because she was so prominent in the white nationalist movement, she was sort of considered like the heir to the white nationalist movement in terms of leadership, and in fact, had like run for political office and won. That there was like some news article, and somebody on the campus discovered her identity as a prominent white nationalist figure, and so she was outed. And when she was outed, like hatred rained down on her. Right, people gave her the finger. They asked her not to come back to clubs. She was really like blacklisted, and from she continued to attend school and began to sort of go to dinners at at at this one kid who was the one kid who was willing to be friendly and give her a chance, and that one kid who she went to dinner at had a roommate who was this strong social justice advocate. Her name was Allison Gornick, and she was like, “I am not going to interact with that guy. He is bad news, and I don’t want to condone his beliefs, and so I’m just going to ignore him and stay away. But then, at one point, they were on this small boat, and so they had nowhere to go. And so she was kind of forced to interact with him. And what she discovered was this kid, this kid who, in her mind, in Allison’s mind, really identified with abhorrent, hateful views, was actually kind of sweet and quirky. And from there they sort of developed this really tentative friendship. And Allison was really concerned, like, what does it mean that I’m going to be friends with somebody who identifies with such hateful ideology? What does it mean about me? And what is he at the time he take it to mean about how I’m feeling about those views? And and is that okay with me? And in order to deal with that feeling of discomfort, what Allison ended up doing was asking if Adrian would be willing to engage in regular conversation to sort of oh sorry, my light just went off to understand what each each side thought and felt about white nationalist ideology, and Adrienne agreed to do it. And so from there, they started having these conversations, and they would have like one conversation to every five conversations about white nationalist ideology, and the other conversations were about more neutral topics: their hopes, their dreams, what the campus food was like, and they became friends. And through this like willingness to try to understand and see as legitimate, even if you didn’t agree, what ended up happening is that Adrienne ultimately gave up on white nationalism, which meant giving up her home community, becoming estranged from her family, really leaving like all the whole world that she had known and been quite devoted to, and I think it really just shows the power. And obviously, it’s an n of one. It’s not like this is a scientific thing that you can do, but what I think it demonstrates is the power of connection and and also, what’s possible when we really get to know somebody?
Yael Schonbrun 23:24
And I will say one more thing, which is that I think we’re so quick to reduce people to their worst behaviors and their their most unappealing beliefs, objectionable beliefs, and we do that because it feels safer. But what it does is, it creates an impossibility of getting to know and connecting and collaborating with people who feel differently than we do. And when we can say, you know, that is one part of a much larger, more complex person, and can I look for the humanity, the the thing that I can connect with? We create not only possibility for people to change and become less extreme, and the research does show that when we feel psychologically safe, we are likely to become less extreme in our views. But it also creates opportunity, and this goes back to our earlier conversation, to capture parts of reality that we don’t have access to because our views are focused, our attention is focused in a different direction, and so I think there’s all this potential that we lose when we say that person has bad beliefs, that person has done awful things, and therefore I am not going to interact with them. Right? We lose that possibility of helping each other grow and of accessing broader truths and of collaborating on things that we can agree on.
Sonya Looney 24:43
Yeah, I remember like that. I’ve been trying not to take as many notes when I read books because I realize like by the time I get to the podcast, it’s just like all of these like half-written ideas, and I can’t make sense of them anyway. So I only had a few notes I wrote with your book because I was trying hard not to, and one of them I wrote was separate the person from. The beliefs, and that was just so so helpful. And also, you know, separating people’s actions at times from the person, like it makes me think of like the Ted Lasso scene. I like I think it was like when Nate had done some done something horrible, and Ted Lasso said something like, “Well, I don’t know about you, but I don’t want to judge somebody based on the actions of their worst moment, yeah. I feel like so many of us do. I mean, I I’ve done that. Like so many of us thought about that
Yael Schonbrun 25:26
moment from Ted Lasso, but I’m remembering it now, and I remember being like, “Yeah, go Ted. Yeah, it’s so true, right? Like it’s so easy to say, “Well, you did or said an awful thing. I can’t be around someone like you. You’re too toxic, right? But people are so much more complicated, and also, we’ve all done bad things. Like if somebody were to say to me, “I’m going to judge you only based on your worst behaviors, they wouldn’t hang out with me, right? Because we’ve all been guilty of doing things that we’re not Proud of,
Sonya Looney 26:01
yeah. That’s and another thing that you read about in your book, similar but not the same thing, is like perspective taking versus perspective getting. I’d never heard of perspective getting, and I always talk about you got to widen your perspective and take the perspective of somebody else. So can you tell us about that? Because I just loved it.
Yael Schonbrun 26:20
Yeah, this is really cool research out of the University of Chicago. There’s a researcher there by the name of Nick Eppley, and he has two books, both of which I really like. But the research that this, well, I think it’s in both of his books. But I loved Mind Wise by Nick Eppley. For those of you who are listening, who are avid readers, it’s a terrific book. He has this research that looks at how accurate we are when we take perspective. When we sort of, you know, there’s this advice that is just kind of worldwide of like, you know, you can’t judge someone until you’ve walked a mile in their shoes. So imagine what it’s like to walk a mile in their shoes. And because we’re so good at theory of mind, or we think we’re so good. We actually we’re pretty good, but we’re just not perfect. But we are pretty good at being like, okay, like I know this about you, and I can see that about you, and we’ve talked enough that I can kind of take a guess at like the way that you approach the world or the kind of person that you are, and so I can imagine, you know, this is how you would feel, or this is how you would act in that kind of a situation, right? I can sort of imagine myself into you, take on your perspective, and take a guess at what you’re thinking or what you’re going to do next. We’re relatively good at that. The problem is not even that we’re not good at it; it’s that our accuracy isn’t as high as our confidence, so we think we’re really, really good, and we’re only good, right? So there’s like a space between how accurate we are and how accurate we think we are. And what’s more, and this is research that I bring up all the time in the therapy room, when we’re in close relationship with people, our accuracy doesn’t go up that much; might go up a little bit, but our confidence goes up way high. And so, the space between how good we are at guessing what other people think, what they feel, what they mean with whatever they say goes up a little bit. But our confidence skyrockets. We’re like, I know exactly what you’re going to say before you even say it. Like, I know exactly how you’re going to react. I know from that facial expression exactly what you’re thinking, and we’re not actually good as we as good as we think, and that’s the problem. So we’re not actually. And what one thing that I will say is that when we are asked, when we’re asked by other people, or when we ask ourselves to take the perspective of others, it’s not a bad thing to do. Our our sort of empathy and and sort of kindness and compassion goes up, which is great, but the research shows that our our accuracy doesn’t go up as much as we think it does. Right, the space between what we think and what we think we know it gets bigger. But what does help, and I think this is really fascinating. Is perspective getting, and what that means is, rather than saying like, let me think hard about what Sonya might think or feel or do in this kind of situation, let me ask her, right? So I’m asking you to give me insights, and if I stay receptive and open to it, then my accuracy can go up, right? Then my knowledge of what’s actually true about how you’re thinking and feeling and what you think that you would do improves, and that’s like the thing that we forget is like we can’t imagine what it’s like to be in somebody else’s skin, and even when we do, we carry our own biases with that. But what we can do is we can say, “Hey, what is it like to be in your skin? Tell me about that. And if we’re open and receptive, that’s good information that increases what we know, and that’s a powerful thing.
Sonya Looney 29:59
What if. People are afraid of asking clarifying questions because I mean, there’s lots of reasons why people might be afraid to to crack that open. But a lot of times, it takes a lot of courage to just ask that question. How can people do that?
Yael Schonbrun 30:15
Well, it depends on the setting. I mean, I have the great privilege of being a therapist, so in the therapy room, it’s free for all. I get to ask, and and it feels good. One other thing that I’ll say: so Nick Eppley’s second book is called A Little More Social, and he shares a ton of his research that shows that we worry a lot about whether we’re being too pushy and too nosy and too inquiring, and actually, people generally like it, right? You you do have to kind of read the room.
Sonya Looney 30:52
Can I interrupt really quick with an example? Please. For some reason, I am really uncomfortable asking people what they do for work because it’s a very weird thing. Because number one, I’m worried that they’re gonna like say, “What if they don’t work, or they can’t work, or something? Then I like worry, oh, they’re gonna feel bad because like I’ve asked them about their work and they’re gonna think I’m judging them or something. Or like, what if they think that I’m labeling them and putting them in a box because of their profession, because like I don’t like it when people do that to me. So my worry about what other people are going to think about a question I’m answering prevents me from asking the most basic question. So I’ve talked to my husband about this a lot, and I think this kind of goes with what you’re talking about right now.
Yael Schonbrun 31:37
Yeah, well, I mean that’s so interesting. That’s interesting that you feel compelled to ask people what they do for work, but you don’t like being asked it because, right? There’s sort of a mismatch there, which I which I find interesting. And the the biggest tip that I have for that is to name the fear. Like I think sometimes it just kind of softens it if we’re like, I’m dying to ask you this thing, but I’m worried you’ll take it the wrong way. A, it’s a little bit of humor diffuses the situation. B, gives people a chance to be like, Yeah, I actually wouldn’t want you to ask that. It’s you kind of asking for permission. Like, would it be okay? And if it’s not, then great. Now you know. And B, it does kind of ask the question. So if it is on the table to find out that information, that’s great too. So, it would be something like, “I’m a little, I’m a little leery of you thinking I’m going to put you in a box by asking you what you do for a living, but I’m also kind of curious. Can I ask? And and that can kind of make it a little bit easier to approach. But again, I think a lot of the time when we’re afraid to ask, the it’s not that nothing bad will ever happen and that people will never feel pigeonholed by your question or feel like it’s an insensitive thing to ask about. But I think that it’s sort of like the bark is worse than the bite. Nick Eppley actually has this other body of research that shows that like we’re a lot more afraid to have difficult conversations because we remember the ones that went so badly, but our anticipation sort of magnifies the likelihood that it’ll go badly when often it goes just fine, and and so that’s kind of the same thing I think that comes up with your worry about asking a question. Sometimes it might go badly. Sometimes somebody might say, “I kind of wish you hadn’t asked that. I’m feeling a little uncomfortable. But far more often than not, it will be just fine. But our brain kind of amplifies the potential bad thing and makes it seem much more likely than it actually
Sonya Looney 33:40
is. Yeah, like another thing, I love that you talked about Lindsay Gibson’s book and her work, “Adult Children of Emotionally Immature Parents. Like that book actually changed my life, because there’s a lot of us that have hyper vigilance from growing up with an emotionally immature and volatile parent. So you’re afraid to, you know, upset somebody because of what it costs you as a child. So when I think about like the theory of mind, like the mind reading and the tiptoeing and like the the making meaning, all the anxiety that comes from theory of mind and from asking clarifying questions, learning how to feel safe so that you can, you know, ask questions that you’re not gonna, you know, literally be unsafe if you do that is is really important work.
Yael Schonbrun 34:29
Yeah, yeah, it’s so interesting. I mean, I love how you described it, and I think you know, so many like the reason that Lindsey Gibson’s book has been so successful is like that is an all too common experience to have grown up in this kind of environment where you have to have this antenna up for like, what is the other person feeling? Because I need to anticipate it and manage myself so that I don’t set something terrible off. And so we have this sort of like hyper attuned antenna. Sorry, now there’s. Instruction noise.
Sonya Looney 35:01
Barely.
Yael Schonbrun 35:02
Oh, amazing. Okay, if it doesn’t bother you, then that’s fine. So, for people who have this kind of like hyper attuned antenna, the problem is is that we start to think, and I count myself among these people, that that antenna is accurate, and that’s the problem. Is like it’s tuned to a particular frequency of a particular kind of childhood experience that isn’t going to replicate by and large, and so it again is going to lead us to being overconfident that we’re understanding other people and that we can approach it just right and set it up so that nothing bad ever happens, but because we’re still dealing with humans, and humans are unpredictable and variable, and whatever childhood experience that you had with a caregiver isn’t going to replicate with other relationships because those people are different people, that that antenna actually isn’t going to do you good. But the problem is we’re so habitual about reading the room and being like, well, I need to make sure that everything is safe and that everything is managed. And there, I think that awareness is a big, big key to unlocking that. I also think acceptance of like we are going to feel that discomfort of uncertainty, and can we, in a sense, like befriend it? Like this uncertainty and this anxiety about making sure that I am perfectly pleasing and manage the room and manage all the feelings. It’s because I care. Like I want to do right by other people. I want to do right by myself. But ultimately, it it can really get in the way of me being authentic and and sort of present and doing the things that are important to me, and so can I sort of say like thank you, mind and body, for trying to help me be the best person I can be, and then sort of unhook from it and turn to something that feels more valuable and more useful. I do think that it is one of those things that we is just going to be along for the ride. If if it’s something that was formed early in childhood, it’s hard to sort of eradicate it completely. But like appreciating where it comes from and then figuring out how to be skillful even in its presence is is really helpful, right? And and also just like recognizing that a really big antenna doesn’t mean you’re always accurate either.
Sonya Looney 37:19
I’m grateful for the visual that you gave me that I can now use in my own life, but like one of the things that I was so excited about, just even the title of your book, is like if we are. I think many of us go through life with this antenna, and I actually would argue there’s probably a generational thing happening for like Gen X millennials. It’s probably a parenting, a way of parenting back in the day, and like a lack of just how the work that people did on themselves because it just wasn’t necessarily available. But you know, I think that a lot of us want to feel understood. We want to be able to be authentic. We want to be able to trust others, but we’re too afraid to try because of because we think we already know what’s going to happen, or we’re too afraid of what might happen, so in doing that, we’re actually not allowing ourselves to feel seen and understood, and we’re also not allowing others to feel seen and understood. So, like recognizing that that antenna is there and how it’s impacting you. Like I remember my I don’t know if this is too personal for the podcast, but like my therapist told me like you’re not being authentic. You don’t actually have trust in your relationships, and I was like, “What do you mean? I’m really authentic. I’m an open book, blah blah blah. But it’s like, she was right. Like when push comes to shove, when I’m uncomfortable, I’ll just eat it and I’ll just like people please because I’m too afraid to say what I need. And so the work for me has been learning how to say what I need so that I can be understood and I can understand, you know, where other people and my partner are coming from, and so having your book, having like it all written out in this way, is going to help me even more because you have so many great communication cues of how to even bring things up when you’re like afraid to bring them up. That is disarming and builds rapport, and even if you can’t agree, you can still understand one another.
Yael Schonbrun 39:04
Thank you so much, and thank you for sharing that because I’m sure a lot of people can relate to that experience of like when I feel anxious, I sort of just put on my protective shield and act as if I, whatever way I think other people would want me to act. But I will say, you know, there’s something so powerful about the therapy room and what happens in there, and I think it’s all about feeling understood. I mean, this is what Carl Rogers discovered in the 1950s and 60s. It’s like if you’re meeting with a therapist and you’re telling your story, and you’re finally like in a place where you like, I can tell you all the dirty things and the uncomfortable things and be real because it just stays in here, and the therapist responds with like compassion and empathy and curiosity, and is like, oh, I get it, and you really feel like they do. There is something so transformative about that, right? We are hungry for that experience of. Being deeply understood for who we really are, and when that happens, it’s so healing, right? It like we feel fully alive and seen and valued, and it is such a good feeling. It’s so powerful, and I think that doesn’t have to be something we just get in therapy, right? Or even something that we just get in our most intimate relationships. Like we can practice offering that, and the more we offer it, the more likely we are to get it. And it and we’re just humans are hungry for understanding, right? It’s a part of being human, and we don’t always have this skill. Sometimes it’s because we weren’t brought up being understood. Sometimes it’s because we’re on our screens so much, and that kind of interferes with it. But in any case, I I do think this like skill, this complex set of skills, really of understanding others and of being understood, is really undervalued because it’s really so such a powerful experience, and we’re all so hungry for it.
Sonya Looney 41:05
Yeah, and then I’m kind of circling back, but like earlier, we were talking about how we think we understood what happened, and our and some I’ll use our partner. Our partner also thinks they understood what happened, but we saw different things. I wanted to give an example. There was like my husband was going to go take a nap, and I had a race the next day. And he and he had I did not hear it, but he said to me, “Well, when you need my help, come wake me up. And I had the kids, and I I didn’t hear him say, “When you need my help, come wake me up. So I just experienced him going upstairs. He’s like sleeping all afternoon, and I’m getting ready for this race, and the kids are around, and I’m stressed out, and I’m getting more angry and agitated and agitated, and then when he got up, I was brave and I I told him how I was feeling, which you know in the past me wouldn’t have would have just like eaten it, and he’s like, “What do you mean? I told you you could come wake me up whenever you needed me, and I just didn’t even hear it at all. And so if I hadn’t been brave enough to bring up that conversation and be authentic and trust the relationship. I wouldn’t have known that there was my reality was actually wrong that I missed a very crucial piece of information because of whatever reason.
Yael Schonbrun 42:11
Yes, that is such a good example because for the exact reason. So, a it will happen, right? Your partner will say something, your friend will say something. Your work colleague will say something. Your political opponent will say something, and you either heard it in a different way than they meant it, or you didn’t hear it at all. Right? That is going to happen because our attention is finite, right? And and we’re distracted, and sometimes people don’t speak up, and sometimes we, you know, just miss whatever the thing is. And if we sort of then take that information and make a story from it that makes us feel a particular way about the person, and we’re wrong, and then we don’t find out, I mean, that’s a recipe for compounding misunderstanding. Because then you could imagine Sonya doesn’t say anything to her partner; she’s just like starts to believe like oh my partner’s the kind of guy who goes to bed and doesn’t even worry if his partner needs to prepare for a race or needs a break from the kids. Oh, he’s that kind of person right now. Now you have this filter, and now you’re going to start to interpret all sorts of behaviors and conversations through that filter, and you never even had a chance to recognize, like you weren’t even right the first time, right? You missed something that would have set you on a totally different path, and so it’s so powerful that you were brave to say, like, “Hey, I I didn’t like that you went up without sort of making a plan with me, and it’s so skillful that you let in him saying, “No, that wasn’t what happened. Because what often happens with couples that are not healthy is that it feels so true that our partner would do that that when they say that isn’t what I did, we say, “Yeah, right, right. We kind of dismiss it rather than allowing that information to update how we understand one another, that is hard to do, right? The willingness to change how we understood something is cognitive effort, right? It requires admitting that you got it wrong. Not easy to do, and it requires changing what you think happened, and that requires us to be humble, and then make the cognitive shift, which is effortful. So all of these pieces, and and this is a big part of what I think my book is really trying to say, is like understanding is not a passive process; it is a very active and difficult process. We will misunderstand because life is complicated, and we’re gonna miss that our partner said, like, wake me up when you need me. But in order to update our understanding, all of these pieces have to be things that we do, and they are important to do to keep relationships on the right side of understanding, and it’s worth the effort. But it doesn’t come for free. It’s not a passive process.
Sonya Looney 45:04
I love that. That’s so powerful. That makes me think about in your book. You talk about the importance of positive regard, and I think that’s kind of what you’re like having positive regard for the people around you, even when there’s a misunderstanding. Can you tell us more about positive regard?
Yael Schonbrun 45:19
Yeah. So positive regard again was something that came from Carl Rogers, the great humanist. Sometimes I think like all of good psychology came from Carl Rogers, and we’re all just recycling his stuff. But I’m sure there’s more than that. But yeah, so he he had this idea of like seeing the good in people, right? Like really striving to see the good in people as being like this this cornerstone of what good therapy did, and what I think is really cool is that modern research. There’s a guy out of the University of Haifa called Guy Ichikov, who does research on what he calls high quality listening, and it has these three components. One is attention, right? You have to like take in what people are communicating to you. the second is comprehension, so you have to like intellectually like decode what they’re saying, and the third component is positive intention, which is basically positive regard, and it’s the idea of like can I see the good in somebody, and this kind of goes back to what we were talking about earlier, which is that requires us sometimes, maybe even often, to not reduce somebody down to their worst thought, belief, behavior, in order to continue to see something of value, either in what the person is communicating or who they are, and through the book, I interviewed all sorts of people who I would call super understanders, and across the board, this was the characteristic that super understanders have in common: is that they’re willing to look for the good in others, even when it is exceptionally hard to do. Right? That’s true of a detective interviewing a serial killer and and sexual assault perpetrator. That’s true of an FBI chief hostage negotiator who worked to defuse situations where somebody was taking hostages and often murdering people. Like these people were willing to even see the good in people who had done terrible, terrible things, not because they were condoning it, and in fact they were not, but because there is value in not reducing people down to their worst parts again. In their case, like to collect valuable information to know, like is this safe or is it not, or what needs to be done with this person in order to keep the community safe going forward. Also, information about like how does somebody end up doing something so terrible? Like what are the precursors and how can we understand that? But also to develop a relationship where forward movement can be made, either with behavior, right, keeping other people safe, but also healing what isn’t going well for that person. Because often people do bad things because, like, they need something. So, can we figure out what they need and get that need met in a healthier way? So, positive regard is really important. So those are like the more extreme cases. But what I find is that in everyday relationships, when we’re hurt, it is very very hard to reach for positive regard, and it’s because we get self protective. And if we have positive regard, we feel vulnerable to the other person, and so the practice is figuring out how to offer positive regard, how to give benefit of the doubt to people, even in those moments where we’re hurt, and that’s a practice, and that’s not an easy practice. It’s actually quite a hard practice, but when we can do it, relationships are far more likely to recover from ruptures. We’re far more likely to get our own needs met, and in both directions, we’re much more likely to be understood. Right? Somebody who feels you seeing past something crappy that they said to you and willing to kind of give you the benefit of the doubt is much more likely to try to understand how you felt and to try to make amends for the way that you were hurt, right?
Yael Schonbrun 49:04
Whereas if you say you did a bad thing and now I can never look at you the same, and I think you’re a terrible person, they’re far less likely to be interested in understanding you, and they’re far less likely to try to make amends. And so positive regard is not easy, but it is such an important thing. And I think too much in our modern society, we’ve said it’s not worth the effort. Bad people don’t deserve it, and I think that’s a huge mistake. And I think the research bears that out.
Sonya Looney 49:31
I also wanted to ask you about just resentment in couples because I’ve noticed that. Oh, my friend is calling it the Great Divorce, but there’s a lot of people who either have young children, like I just hear, you know, there’s lots of conversations I’m having with people all around, or people who you know their kids are older and they’re staying together because of the kids. And I know you’ve written, you have a great Substack, and people should definitely relate relational riffs should go check it out because you’ve you’ve actually written about this. But like, I think what we’re. Talking about and a lot of our examples are situations that aren’t quote really far gone, where you can have positive regard, you can have humility. What if somebody is so far down the resentment? Like I, I don’t know. Did you guys talk? Did you write about the Gottmans, like the Four Horsemen, like yeah? I wrote that
Yael Schonbrun 50:17
Washington Post piece about that.
Sonya Looney 50:19
Yes. So like when they’re so far gone with a contempt and resentment that it’s hard for them to have positive regard and humility. Like, what can people do to start backing away from that? Because their confirmation bias is so strong. How can they get back from that?
Yael Schonbrun 50:35
Yeah, that is so tricky. And and John Gottman’s research shows that like among the four horsemen, like contempt is like the toxic sludge that really makes it hard for our relationship to recover, and and I I see that all the time, and it is not easy, right? And and what I what I think is the most helpful advice that I have, and I don’t even know if it’s all that helpful, but it’s just to kind of acknowledge that that’s where you’re at. Like right now, I cannot see the good in you, and I think one of the mistakes that I see people making in couples therapy is to like feel that way and expect that you can figure out like how to sustain the relationship anyway. Like you can’t like if the resentment is that powerful and that toxic, you’re not going to feel better until something about that changes. And I do think there are some ways to recover from it. So one is to create a shared reality, right? So this is going back to the shared reality. But what that requires, and this is really hard when you’re hurting, right? When you’re feeling that bitter, like I feel like I’ve been trodden on for too long, and I don’t think you care, and I don’t know that I can forgive you because you don’t seem to want to make it up to me, right? And I don’t want to see your point of view because I’m I’m hurting too much. And would you ever see my point of view? Like this is sort of like the internal monolog that people get into, if you can get into a place of I am willing to try to understand why you got to the place that you did, I’d love it if you would do the same for me, and that we can kind of create this shared understanding of how we arrived here, and figure out once we understand that where to go from here, that you can be recoverable. The problem, and I think this is maybe what you’re pointing to, is that sometimes the hurt is so deep, the damage is so far gone, that it’s hard to do that work. Like we’re just too hurt, and I see this all the time in my couples therapy practice where people come in and like even me reflecting, empathizing, showing understanding to somebody’s partner feels so unjust. Like people feel harmed by me reflecting on what their partner is experiencing. No, they they could never be hurt like that. They’re just putting on a show for you, and if it’s that far gone and that deep, I’ll point out to people like it seems like it’s hard for you to acknowledge that your partner may be having an experience that is worth understanding, and that’s okay, right? Like that may just be where you’re at, but let’s not do the charade of of pretending that you’re going to understand if you’re not there. Like you cannot be there. That is okay. But let’s acknowledge that reality, and figure out like what is it that you need to be able to have the the emotional psychological space to be curious about your partner. Because maybe you just need to be in individual therapy and get a lot of validation, and figure out like who you are and and what would be amends that would be useful to tell your partner I need this in order for us to get to the next place. But sitting in a room and saying like you don’t have a right to feelings, you don’t have a right to want things, you don’t have a right to have your own interpretation of what’s happened really gets people stuck and deeper in the hole of resentment in both directions because somebody is not going to respond to that with compassion and curiosity and amends. They’re going to respond to that in a defensive way. That’s just human nature, and so I think to recognize like where am I at? What what do I need in order to?
Yael Schonbrun 54:23
And I think resentment is a fine emotion. It’s a useful emotion. Like okay, I feel like I’ve been taken advantage of and and trodden upon, and I need certain things to be different. All good, good information. But in order to do something with it, we need to be able to say this is how I feel. Let me understand how you feel. So, can you do that? And if you can’t, then work individually first.
Sonya Looney 54:49
I have one last question. Can you over try trying to understand people?
Yael Schonbrun 54:56
Yes, I have a chapter on this called “Drop the Rope.” And I describe my own sordid history of trying too hard to be understood, and I think this is a tricky line to walk, right? Because like we want to understand, and we want to be understood, and we want to do that skillfully, and it it is hard work on the one hand, and I’m saying like do the work. On the other hand, if you are insisting on being understood and insisting on understanding better constantly, and you’re getting a lot of pushback, and you find that it is creating more conflict, or in in my case, like it could be like a sense of invalidation, like I need you to understand me. You’re not understanding me, and the other person is feeling like I’m telling them you’re doing a bad job. And right, like if you can kind of see you’re you’re digging deeper, the the recommendation that I have is not necessarily to stop understanding efforts entirely, but it’s at least temporarily to drop the rope, like give it a pause. Understanding is hard work, and if you pursue it too strenuously, people are going to feel overwhelmed and backed into a corner, and that is not likely to result in more understanding. And so, you do have to be a bit gentle about your efforts at understanding and being understood. Recognizing it is important, don’t give up on it. Do work hard, but don’t pursue it at all costs, and don’t pursue it too aggressively or insistently, because that can cause people to feel really overwhelmed and and sort of on the defense from your efforts.
Sonya Looney 56:37
I have one more. So a lot of the examples in the book are about adults, and you know I’m a parent of young children. I’m always trying really hard to get the communication right with my children to help them feel seen and understood. Does any of this differ in how you would communicate with children?
Yael Schonbrun 56:53
I mean, I think the principles are very much the same, and in fact, what’s fun is so Lindsibin and I have had a number of conversations about the overlap between our books, including her more recent book, which is called “How to Raise an Emotionally Mature Child.
Sonya Looney 57:11
So good, so
Yael Schonbrun 57:12
good. And what I love about her book, I love so many things about her writing. But what I love about this recent book is her emphasis on this idea that our children have an inner world that we don’t know, right? And such as parents, it’s so tempting to say, like, I understand you, I made you, right? Like, I literally made you and have been with you every single day of your life. How could I not understand you? I know everything about you, but we don’t, right? Our children are there even from very early on, they are their own unique selves with an internal life, and that should not scare us. That should be like that’s amazing! Like how awesome, and can we be curious and just in awe of these creatures who are going to surprise us at every turn, and seeing the good in them, even when they behave badly, without agreeing or condoning bad behavior, and being infinitely curious about them, I think, is such a beautiful thing to do as parents. And of course, you know the kinds of questions that you might ask in conversations that you will have will differ, and you know try to be developmentally appropriate. But I think the principle of let’s be a little bit more humble about how well we understand our kids. They are much more likely to. I mean, there’s this paradox of like when we are humble and say like I don’t understand you. That’s amazing. Tell me more. Help me understand better. When we admit the limits of our understanding, people, including our kids, feel more understood. There’s something so respectful about saying like you’re your own person. Teach me about you, and kids love that. Of course they do. We all love that, and so as parents, I think it is incumbent upon us to really like make humility a practice with our kids and and give respect to their inner world, and have them help you understand them better. I also think that parenting-we often forget, like how much parenting is a way that we model relationships for our kids. Invite them to be curious about you. Invite them to practice understanding you. That is a good thing for them to be learning. And in fact, I do that all the time with my kids. They’re a little bit older than yours, but I think it’s a really lovely thing to be teaching them that this is a gift that you can give in all of your relationships: is being curious and wanting to understand the people that you love just a little better every day.
Sonya Looney 59:36
Well, thank you so much. This was such an awesome podcast. It’s so hard to stop because there’s so many more things that we could be talking about. Where can people find your book? And you do so many different things. It’s just incredible. So much wisdom and insight you’re putting out in the world. Where can people find all of this?
Yael Schonbrun 59:52
Well, I am so grateful to you for having me on, Sonya. You are like a treasure, and I’m so grateful that we are friends and. Addition to book buddies, and thank you so much for these awesome, thoughtful questions, and just for being an awesome human being, and putting so much of your goodness out in the world. People can find out more about me at my website elshonbrun.com y a e l s c h o n b r u n.com, and then the book is sold at all the normal booksellers, and my Substack is relational riffs. And I write each week about relationship science, lots of stuff, ideas from the therapy room, practices from the therapy room, science that is useful in our everyday lives. So come check me out there too.
__________________________________

